Primary research is conducted in the real world. When conducting primary research, the researcher will use one or more methods to collect data directly from the people or the things he or she is studying, rather than from books or articles already written about those things or people. Common methods of primary research are observation, interviewing, and surveys.
Secondary research is the kind of research you do in the library or online. When you are conducting secondary research, you're looking for sources of information that other experts, writers, and thinkers wrote about a subject. This kind of research is considered ‘secondary’ because it relies on data that has already been collected by other researchers.
Source: Forms of Primary Research. Authored by: Jeff Paschke-Johannes. Provided by: Ivy Tech Community College. License: CC BY: Attribution
Confirm that it is a scholarly article. It should be published in a scholarly journal and not a newspaper or popular magazine. The authors should be experts in the field and not journalists. The article must have a reference list. If the article does not have these elements it is not scholarly, and it cannot be a research article.
The article should clearly state that the author(s) conducted research, ran surveys, did experiments, collected data, or otherwise gathered material on their own or with a team of researchers. It must be original research conducted by the authors of the research article, and needs to be identified as such.
A research article is different than a review article, which is a critical evaluation of material that has been previously published. This can be done to assess the state of the literature on a topic (which is a literature review), and to suggest steps for future research.
The abstract often has clues. Look for a sentence that says something like “this study examines…” or “we did research to find…” Such statements indicate that the author probably conducted original research
Research articles typically follow a particular format, and include specific elements that show how the research was designed, how the data was gathered, how it was analyzed, and what the conclusions are. Sometimes these sections may be labeled a bit differently, but these basic elements are consistent:
Abstract: A brief, comprehensive summary of the article, written by the author(s) of the article.This abstract must be part of the article, not a summary in the database.
Introduction: This introduces the problem, tells you why it’s important, and outlines the background, purpose, and hypotheses the authors are trying to test. The introduction comes first, just after the abstract, and is usually not labeled.
Method: Tells the reader in detail how the research was conducted, and may be subdivided into subsections describing Materials, Apparatus, Subjects, Design, and Procedures.
Results: Summarizes the data and describes how it was analyzed. It should be sufficiently detailed to justify the conclusions.
Discussion: The authors explain how the data fits their original hypothesis, state their conclusions, and look at the theoretical and practical implications of their research.
References: Lists the complete bibliography of sources cited in the research article.
The highlighted areas below represent the typical sections found in a scholarly research article. Click the image for an interactive view.
Source: NCSU Libraries. Shared under the Creative Commons Attribution - Noncommercial - Share Alike 3.0 United States License.
Now that you have your article, how do you read it? How you read and take notes on a scholarly journal article is going to affect how you critique it. Check out these tabs for some tips and tricks to consider when reading through these articles.
UNDERSTAND THE AUTHOR
The first thing you need to do in order to read and critique a scholarly journal article is understand the author. To understand the author, keep in mind the following:
*Modified from guides by Pasadena City College, University of New England, and Fitchburg State University.
HOW TO APPROACH THE ARTICLE
Don't be a passive reader. Keep in mind your reason for reading the article.
*Modified from guides by Pasadena City College, University of New England, and Fitchburg State University.
STEPS TO READ THE ARTICLE
Part of being an informed reader is knowing how to read the article.
You are looking through a lot of articles for a specific reason. The quickest and most effective reading method is to understand how the articles are organized and then read specific areas to locate the information you need.
*Modified from guides by Pasadena City College, University of New England, and Fitchburg State University.
ITEMS TO CONSIDER WHEN CRITIQUING AN ARTICLE
HOW TO REFERENCE THE ARTICLE
There are two main ways to reference an article in your paper:
Your program uses APA Style formatting. For more help with APA style and Word document formatting, please visit the APA page of this guide.
*Modified from guides by Pasadena City College, University of New England, and Fitchburg State University.
Identify Scholarly vs Popular Articles
Tell the difference between articles authored by a scholar from articles written by a journalist. (2:37)
Use the following checklist to help you identify scholarly, research-based articles.